Hogan fence posts Vs. Hardwood fence posts
Fencing plays an important role in enhancing the aesthetic appeal and security of any property. A crucial component of any fence is its posts, which determine the durability and strength of the entire structure. Different materials, such as wood, metal, and plastic, can be used to make fence posts. When choosing fence posts for your property, it’s essential to consider your fencing style and what you’re trying to achieve.
Hogan and hardwood are two commonly used materials for fence posts, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages.
At Stock & Noble, we provide the finest fencing materials to properties across Australia and New Zealand. Our products are thoughtfully picked based on their global success and proven safety. We understand the importance of selecting the right fencing materials for your property. While we offer the Hogan Plastic Fence Post, we will provide detailed fact-based information to help you make an informed decision.
In this blog, we will delve into the key differences between Hogan and hardwood fence posts and explore the factors that influence their selection. So, if you’re considering installing a new fence or replacing the existing one, keep reading to gain all the information needed to create a property that matches your vision and budget.
Hogan Fence Posts: An Overview
Hogan fence posts are an excellent option for those looking for durable and low-maintenance fence posts. Made from hard recyclable polyethylene, these 120mm round hollow plastic posts with 8mm wall thickness are available in customisable lengths, with 2.1 and 2.4-metre posts being the most common. The posts come in black, but white or other colours can be requested.
Compared to soft plastic posts, Hogan fence posts are more resistant to bending when exposed to the sun, and they are incredibly durable, rust-resistant, and rot-resistant, making them ideal for harsh weather conditions. They are also lightweight and easy to install.
Typically used in rural properties, Hogan fence posts are suitable for use with flexible rails, particularly Horserail and Legacy Rail. However, it’s important to note that they are not weight-bearing posts, so steel end and corner assemblies are recommended for fences under tension.
Hardwood Fence Posts: An Overview
Hardwood fence posts are a popular choice for those who desire a rustic look on their property. Made from natural wood such as Ironbark, Blackbutt, Spotted Gum, and River Red Gum, these premium quality hardwood posts can add charm to any property. However, they require regular maintenance to prevent rot, termites, and other damage. Additionally, they are vulnerable to weathering and have too many variables which might impact their durability.
There are two types of hardwood fence posts: split posts and rough sawn posts. Split posts are simply split out of a log, resulting in uneven shapes such as triangles or squares. Rough sawn posts are processed at a sawmill producing a uniform size. Due to this extra process they are more expensive. Ironbark is the best hardwood fence post as it is the most durable and almost impervious to termites and rot, lasting over 20 years.
Before painting the hardwood fence posts, it’s recommended to wait up to six months for the timber to dry out. For the best outcome it is recommended that the tannins and sap are allowed to drain out. Hardwood fence posts can be purchased from most rural fencing suppliers and used in rural properties and, in some cases, domestic properties.
Compared to Hogan fence posts, which come in a customisable length and are made of hard recyclable polyethylene, hardwood fence posts require more effort and time to finish. With Hogan posts, installation is easy, and they come in black with a smooth finish. In contrast, hardwood posts have a rough finish that needs to be painted, and the drying time of the timber can prolong the project.
The difference in durability: Hogan fence post vs Hardwood fence post
When comparing the durability of Hogan fence posts to hardwood fence posts, it can be said that timber is generally more durable due to its solid structure and ability to support heavy weight. However, Hogan posts, being made of hollow plastic, can be useful for intermediate posts or when installing lightweight materials such as horserail. Hogan posts also have the advantage of being recyclable and resistant to decay, which makes them a good option in certain situations.
It’s worth noting that the term “hardwood” typically refers to the toughest types of wood, such as Ironbark, and not softer woods like treated pine or cypress. It’ll be worth learning about the problems of timber fence posts.
The difference in cost: Hogan fence post vs Hardwood fence post
When considering the cost of Hogan fence posts versus hardwood fence posts, it’s important to take the long-term expenses into account. While Hogan posts may have a higher initial cost, they are a cost-effective option in the long run. This is because they are durable and require minimal maintenance which includes no painting and can save you money on repairs and replacements over time. Additionally, their ease of installation can save you money on labour costs.
In contrast, hardwood split posts may have a similar upfront cost, they do not offer a uniform look, need painting and might require regular maintenance which can add up over time. The cost of wood may also fluctuate, making it difficult to accurately estimate the total cost of the fence.
Cost of Ironbark square post 100x100mm, (rough sawn 2.1m) – $84.00
Ironbark Split post 2.1m – $22.00-$26.00
Hogan plastic fence post costs $38.5, including GST.
The difference in longevity: Hogan fence post vs Hardwood fence post
Hogan posts come with a 20-year warranty, whereas timber posts cannot be guaranteed in the same way. While experienced professionals may estimate that a hardwood like Ironbark can last for 20-30 years, the reality is that two pieces of timber, even if placed 3 meters apart in the same ground, can perform differently due to the unpredictable nature of natural products. Additionally, the source of the timber can also impact its performance, as the same species sourced from different regions may react differently.
Although hardwood is generally known for its durability, the variability in its performance cannot be overlooked. In contrast, Hogan posts offer a greater level of certainty in terms of performance and longevity.
The difference in the installation: Hogan fence post vs Hardwood fence post
When it comes to installation, both Hogan fence posts and hardwood have their pros and cons.
One of the key benefits is that Hogan posts are lightweight and easy to handle, which makes the installation process quicker and more efficient. In contrast, wooden fence posts require a more labour-intensive installation process due to their heavy weight.
For fencing contractors, timber may be faster to install as compared to Hogan posts, as pre-drilling holes are required for the latter.
The difference in aesthetics: Hogan fence post vs Hardwood fence post
If you’re aiming for a uniform appearance and a straight fencing line, Hogan posts would likely be the better option.
However, if you prefer the traditional timber post and rail fence look, hardwood would better suit your vision.
Ultimately, it’s a matter of personal preference and depends on the vision you have for your forever property.
If you’re considering Treated Pine fence post to manage cost and maintain a consistent look of timber on your property, it’ll be worth digging deeper into the difference between Treated Pine and Hollow plastic fence posts.
The difference in availability: Hogan fence post vs Hardwood fence post
Timber to date has been readily available but in recent times with the advent of natural disasters and forests being closed to logging, there is an increasing challenge to supply the demand making availability unpredictable.
In contrast, Hogan posts are typically in stock and readily available. In the event of higher demand, there may be a standard two-week lead time.
You can check the availability of Hogan Post for your fencing project by connecting with one of our fencing experts.
The difference in horse safety: Hogan fence post vs Hardwood fence post
If you’re building an equine property, the safety of your horses is paramount.
Hogan posts have the advantage here due to their smooth finish. In contrast, hardwood fence posts may have sharp edges and splinters, posing a potential hazard to horses.
Another pro of Hogan posts is that horses are unable to chew on plastic, whereas timber is a favoured snack for them, which can weaken the fence post and potentially cause harm to the horses.
Which are better fence posts for your property? Hogan fence posts vs Hardwood fence posts.
In conclusion, selecting the right fence posts for your property is an important decision that requires careful consideration.
Hogan and hardwood fence posts are two commonly used materials, each with its advantages and disadvantages. Hogan plastic fence posts are durable, lightweight, and require minimal maintenance, making them a cost-effective option in the long run. On the other hand, hardwood fence posts add a rustic charm to properties but require regular maintenance, are vulnerable to weathering, and have too many variables that can impact their durability.
If you’re faced with the decision between Hogan fence posts and hardwood posts, consider the following:
- If you’re using Horserail, Hogan posts may be the better option. They offer a uniform appearance and are specifically designed for use with flexible plastic rails. Additionally, they require little to no maintenance, whereas timber posts would need to be painted and could be damaged if horses decide to chew on them. Hogan posts are also more affordable than premium rough sawn hardwood fence posts.
- On the other hand, if you’re aiming for a more traditional post and rail fence, hardwood fence posts may be the way to go. The premium quality hardwood fence posts offer a durable solution that will last longer than other options and add to the aesthetics of your property.
It’s also important to consider your fencing style and what you’re trying to achieve before making a decision. It would be worth learning the best combination of fence posts and rails.
If you have more questions on how to choose a fence post for your property, installation, cost and availability, feel free to speak to our fencing experts. You can book a personalised consultation and get all your queries answered. We will help you at every step to create a safe and beautiful property.